Jurgen Klopp wants to buy a goal-scoring winger. He hasn’t told me this personally, nor has he said it publicly, but based on his targeting of Leroy Sane, Ousmane Dembele and possibly Mario Gotze and Sadio Mane, it seems a certainty that Klopp wants to add more goals into the trio who play behind his lone striker.
Sane was the first player linked with the Reds after Klopp took over but very quickly, and rather strangely, his supposed asking price sky-rocketed from about £20million to anything from £35million to £50million depending on which newspaper or website you read.
With the Reds unlikely to pay that sort of money for a player who’s proven little, despite unquestionable talent, the next name up was Ousmane Dembele. The fantastically gifted wideman had burst onto the season this past season with Rennes and began tearing apart any and all Ligue 1 defences that dared stand in his way. With 12 goals in 26 league matches he put everyone on notice that, along with Anthony Martial and Kingsley Coman, he would be leading the next generation of French football. Unfortunately for Liverpool they weren’t the only club keen to add him to their ranks and were beaten to the punch by Borussia Dortmund, who secured his signature on a five year contract.
After Dembele came a deviation from what seemed a clearly defined profile of a target. Mario Gotze seems an odd fit in this Liverpool team given what they need and what he offers. There’s no doubting his talent, or his production in his previous spell under Klopp, but having him, Firmino and Coutinho in the one team will result in many of the same problems they experience when Adam Lallana is paired with the Brazilians. Gotze is unquestionable a better and far more talented player than Lallana but buying him wouldn’t solve the problems Liverpool experience in attack. Lack of width, pace in wide areas, runners breaking behind the defence, Gotze provides none of that. Nevertheless Gotze went from being “wanted” to “close” in a millisecond before news came from Germany that he had decided to stay with Bayern.
When news that Gotze was unlikely broke, Sadio Mane was linked by all and sundry, with rumoured prices ranging from a silly £25million to a frankly ridiculous £40million. Mane is one of the Premier League’s most inconsistent players and personally I’d avoid this move like the plague. Liverpool need to learn their lesson, “Premier League proven” means nothing and after years of overpaying for mediocre midtable Premier League players the club need to look abroad where the prices paid are far more in-line with the talent purchased. Mane scored in only eight of the 37 Premier League games he featured in last season, had a poor shots to goals ratio, and isn’t even an actual winger. Mane is a striker. He plays in a front two, off the main striker or as an inside forward in a front three. And inside-forwards are different creators to wingers. Mane scored 14 goals in all competitions last season, only one of them came from him starting in a wide position to begin the attack. He plays centrally and Liverpool already have Roberto Firmino and Philip Coutinho to play centrally behind Daniel Sturridge or Divock Origi, their need is for someone who actually plays wide.
So with that said, I thought I’d take a look at a few options who I believe would represent good signings, and good value for money, to fill the wide role for Jurgen Klopp’s team. Some fit what seemed to have been the defined profile, pace and goals with natural width, while others are more in line with Gotze stylistically. I’ve tried to be as realistic as possible and taken the rumoured £40million price for Mane and tried to come in £10million below that at the very least. While some might look at a couple of name on this list and think they are not players Liverpool could sign, think of it this way; If Liverpool offered the fee Southampton wanted for any of these players there’s no question it would be accepted. With the exception of six or seven, every club in Europe is a selling club. For the players themselves, there’s nobody on this list earning even half of what Mane is rumoured to be wanting, £120,000 p/w. If Liverpool offered that, the players would sign. Take that as a starting point, and work backwards.
Hakim Ziyech
Club: FC Twente   Age: 23   Nationality: Moroccan   Estimated Price: £15million
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fmmUVfEW5aw
Riyad Mahrez set the league alight this past season and went from virtual unknown to a player every fan wants their club to sign. Unfortunately, his immense form this past season means that the price for him has skyrocketed to somewhere in the £35m-40mil range and that’s a big gamble on a player who may just have been a one season wonder. So why not find the next Mahrez? I believe Ziyech has the potential to match Mahrez and maybe even become a better player. His form for FC Twente has been nothing short of spectacular and he’d cost less than half, probably close to a third, of what Leicester will ask for Mahrez.
Ziyech brings goals and creativity. He brings versatility and work rate. Most importantly for Liverpool, he brings fantastic set-pieces. He’d be a very good fit for Liverpool and wouldn’t cost an outlandish amount.
Nabil Fekir
Club: Lyon   Age: 22   Nationality: French   Estimated Price: £18million
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AxBsW4i8e3c
Everyone knows about Lyon’s star striker Alexandre Lacazette but his team-mate Nabil Fekir might be an even better signing for a club like Liverpool. A gifted creator who can score goals and play anywhere across the attack Fekir became a star for Lyon in the 14/15 season when he bagged 13 goals while creating chances galore for those around him. A torn ACL in September of 2015 robbed him of his 15/16 season but he return in April and pretty quickly looked like he hadn’t been away.
Fekir has been rumoured to want a move to the Premier League and the harsh reality for Lyon is that they can’t hold on to their biggest stars long-term. While Fekir may stay for one more season if teams are scared off by the recent ACL injury, it will be no surprise if he moves to a top club this summer.
Sofiane Boufal
Club: Lille   Age: 22   Nationality: Moroccan   Estimated Price: £15million
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VC_yiqAbzsA
Arguably one of the finest dribblers in world football, Boufal is a player who has recent been mentioned in connection with Liverpool. He joined Lille in January 2015 and has been in impressive form ever since, scoring and creating goals for a team that struggled desperately to find the net between the time Eden Hazard left, and he arrived. He spent 5 months playing in the team with Divock Origi so there’s an established relationship there which may sway him towards Merseyside over the other options he’s bound to have.
He normally plays off the left but with Coutinho entrenched there he could easily switch to the right. £15million should be enough to land this fantastically talented player.
Anwar El Ghazi
Club: Ajax   Age: 21   Nationality: Dutch   Estimated Price: £18million
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O5kvOwZBpzA
Anwar El Ghazi is the latest potential superstar to come from the Ajax school of witchcraft and wizardry. A tall, powerful winger who possesses powerful shooting from distance in both feet. With a similar build and style of play to Cristiano he’s an exciting prospect who still has a lot to learn as his decision-making can be extremely questionable at times. Ajax would want a big fee for him, because they’re Ajax and they always want big fees, but he’s the type of player who might be worth gambling on. Already a full Dutch international he’s taken the place of Memphis as Holland’s next big thing.
As with some others on this list he probably wouldn’t be an every game starter straight away, but definitely has the talent to become one.
Julian Brandt
Club: Bayer Leverkusen   Age: 20    Nationality: German   Estimated Price: £20million
Brandt was linked to Liverpool in the summer of 2014 when the Reds raided Leverkusen for Emre Can and has likely been monitored since as he is without question one of the brightest young players in the Bundesliga. His progress seemed to stall a bit in the 14/15 season but he bounced back with an excellent 15/16 becoming a valuable source of goals for Leverkusen. An extremely intelligent player, his movement off the ball and ability to always know where his team-mates are at all times are what set him apart. He’s more naturally a creator but showed his goalscoring ability by scoring in six consecutive Bundesliga games this past season.
His versatility and potential have to be appealing to a manager like Klopp, and his work rate is fantastic. Under a manager like Klopp, Brandt could become a world-class player.
Munir El Haddadi
Club: Barcelona   Age: 20    Nationality: Spanish   Estimated Price: £12million
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FqSdX8baR1o
Munir El Haddadi might be the most talented out-and-out attacker Spain have produced since Fernando Torres. A natural goalscorer with the pace and ability to play wide and give fullbacks nightmares he would start for most clubs. Unfortunately for him, Barcelona have three lads called Messi, Neymar and Suarez who block his path. Some Liverpool fans have seen the impact Bojan has had in the Premier League since joining Stoke and have called for the Reds to make a move for him, why not sign a better, younger version.
Barcelona will almost certainly insist on a buy-back clause if they do sell El Haddadi so this may not be the type of deal Liverpool want, but if they miss out on other targets it’s definitely one they should consider.
Ahmed Musa
Club: CSKA Moscow   Age: 23    Nationality: Nigerian   Estimated Price: £18million
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e99Lvu9XfM8
Of all the players on this list, Musa is the most similar to Mane stylistically but unlike the Saints man, he’s an actual winger. While Mane plays upfront, either in a 2 or 3, Musa is a natural wide man who can also play as an inside forward. He’s a cheaper, and in my view more talented, alternative to Sadio Mane with him he shares many traits. He’s pacey, direct and can score goals, but he also tends to go missing in games, and then for stretches of games. There’s clear talent here though, and he has been linked to Leicester for the last few months.
If Klopp does want a player of this ilk, I’d rather Musa than Mane because he would cost roughly half of what Southampton are believed to be asking for Mane and he actually plays the position Liverpool are looking to fill.
Do continue reading as I look at Breel Embolo, Timo Werner, Berardi, Draxler, Marlos Moreno and Gabriel Jesus next!
DEFENDERS!!!!
I’ll do one for centrebacks in the next week or two mate.
Love the format and the analysis
Thanks mate
Excellent read, nice to see a well thought out and actual realistic list as opposed to the consistent FIFA 16 wish lists!
My only concern with any of these is that although some are somewhat household names, none are what you would call the finished article and that’s where LFC seem to have slipped up in recent years. I appreciate we aren’t the power of old and have to be selective, but I personally would be happy with one of those from the list, and an accompanying established wide player. Granted, not too many of those about but an article on that would be good.
Keep up the good work!
Hey mate,
The problem I see for Liverpool when it comes to signing established players in the 24-28 range is that the ones who are good enough for Liverpool are generally ungettable. They’re either already at a top club, or they’re at clubs with eyes on the top 4 and it’ll cost an insane amount to get them, similar to how Southampton have priced Lallana, Lovren and now Mane.
for me, either fekir or musa.
Both really good options I reckon.
A superb article. Reasoned and reasonable in equal measure. Good to read some informative analysis that’s based on honest research. I won’t claim to have known most of those identified by Dave but the majority look like realistic targets, all going well. What appeals most, for me, in this method of recruitment, is the fact that we will not be throwing immoral amounts of monies on over-priced PL players. We have been profligate to an inept degree on transfer policy for far too long now and until we have a root and branch in this dept. of the club we will continue to fail where it matters most. Dave’s article highlights that there is untapped talent out there, and that they don’t have to have been playing in the premier league. Here’s hoping the club are similarly minded.
It would appear that Mane’s better performances, according to Whoscored, have come from out wide as did the majority of his goals. Mane is clearly a very good footballer and a logical buy, however prosaic the scouting might be. He offers what Sterling might have had he stayed (pace on the break, directness, ability to molest players 1v1, and goals; but adds a functioning left foot). On the point maybe someone more qualified than me should do an analysis of LFC PL to foreign buys because with the exception of Carroll and Benteke (both ill-advised but easy to mitigated due to circumstances.) I’d say that they were in fact relatively even with regards to the success rate and that maybe the cost of players on the foreign market has caught up. For instance, I could see all of the players, apart from El Ghazi, you’ve mentioned going fot £10m more than the quoted prices.