Luke Shaw Return Looms as Manchester United Search for Stability Before Liverpool Clash

Manchester United head into the international break with fresh uncertainty surrounding both the first-team picture and the wider direction of the club. A chaotic 4-4 draw with Aston Villa has intensified scrutiny on Michael Carrick, with the pressure mounting after a start to the season that has left United in the Premier League relegation zone.

There are fitness concerns across the squad too. Harry Maguire was forced off at half-time against Villa, with Carrick explaining, “Harry had a bad back. A really bad back spasm that he had with maybe 10-15 minutes to go in the first half. I don’t know how bad it is but, going into the internationals, there should be plenty of time for him to recover.”

Elsewhere, Carlos Baleba is expected to be unavailable for several weeks because of a hamstring problem suffered against Roma. Marcus Rashford also remains sidelined with an ongoing hip issue, and the break will now be used to continue his recovery work rather than stage a comeback.

Luke Shaw Injury Return in Focus

The most immediate point of interest centres on Luke Shaw. According to the Daily Mail, the left-back is targeting a return for Manchester United’s trip to Liverpool after the November international break.

Photo: IMAGO

Shaw has not played since completing 90 minutes against Tottenham on October 10, missing seven matches since. In that spell, United’s shortage of specialist options on the left has become increasingly obvious. Diogo Dalot has been asked to fill in on his weaker side, and the strain of that adjustment has shown. Patrick Dorgu is also pushing to be involved again, which could at least give United greater choice in a problem position.

Manchester United Defence Under Pressure

United’s defensive record remains one of the clearest indicators of their difficulties. They have conceded the joint-most goals in all competitions among clubs in Europe’s top five leagues this season, an alarming return for a side still trying to find basic control in and out of possession.

For that reason, Shaw’s potential availability matters. His return would not solve every structural issue, but it could offer balance, experience and a degree of calm before one of the toughest assignments on the calendar, a visit to Anfield.

Our View

You look at this from Liverpool’s side and the timing is fascinating. A fit Luke Shaw would clearly improve Manchester United, particularly with how exposed they have looked at left-back, but it does not change the wider picture. Their problems seem much bigger than one returning defender. The instability around the manager, the long injury list and a defence shipping goals at that rate all point to a side lacking confidence and cohesion.

Anfield is the last place you want to visit when you are in that state. Even if Shaw makes it, he would be returning to a high-intensity game after a lay-off, and that carries its own risks. Liverpool will see areas to attack, especially if United are still piecing their back line together around late fitness calls.

There is also a broader lesson here about squad planning. When one absence can leave a side this vulnerable in a single position, questions naturally follow. Liverpool have had those issues in the past and paid for them. United seem to be living that now.

All told, Shaw coming back may make the contest more competitive, and no Liverpool supporter will underestimate the rivalry, but the report reads more like a small piece of relief for United than any real shift in the balance. The bigger concerns remain firmly in place.