Liverpool midfield dilemma grows as Trey Nyoni changes Iraola’s options

Liverpool’s midfield plans are being reshaped by a teenager who has made himself increasingly difficult to leave out.

Trey Nyoni began the season seeking opportunities. He now belongs in the discussion about Andoni Iraola’s strongest side, with his composure alongside Alexis Mac Allister offering a promising foundation for Liverpool’s possession game.

As Andy Jones examines in The Athletic, injuries, rotation and fluctuating performances have altered the midfield picture considerably. A combination of Nyoni, Mac Allister and Florian Wirtz now has a credible claim to be Liverpool’s most effective trio.

That remains a judgement rather than an established selection policy. Nevertheless, Nyoni’s progress has implications for players who appeared more certain of their places when the campaign began.

Photo: IMAGO

Nyoni brings composure without solving every problem

Nyoni’s start against Fenerbahce was his third in succession, another indication of the responsibility Iraola is prepared to give the 19-year-old.

His appeal is particularly clear during Liverpool’s build-up. He offers himself in deeper positions, moves the ball promptly and remains available to support the next pass. Those habits help teammates retain options rather than leaving the centre of the pitch unoccupied.

For a side searching for greater consistency, that reliability has value. It allows Liverpool to construct attacks with a midfielder who appears comfortable receiving possession under pressure.

However, his inclusion has not resolved their defensive problems. Liverpool conceded three goals in each of the last three Champions League matches he started.

Those results underline a collective issue. Nyoni can improve the flow of possession, but Liverpool still need better protection when attacks break down and greater concentration around their own penalty area.

Mac Allister’s importance raises contract questions

Mac Allister has become the most dependable reference point in Iraola’s changing midfield.

The Athletic’s figures place him ahead of the other four regularly used midfielders for minutes in all competitions, with 1,021. His ability to operate both at the base of midfield and further forward gives the manager flexibility without requiring an entirely different approach.

That importance makes his contractual situation particularly interesting. According to the report, Mac Allister was told during the summer that Liverpool were not in a position to offer him a new agreement.

Meanwhile, Szoboszlai and Gravenberch have signed extensions, and talks over fresh terms for Nyoni are ongoing.

Those decisions do not dictate selection. They do, however, create a contrast between Liverpool’s longer-term commitments and the player currently providing their most consistent midfield balance.

Szoboszlai and Gravenberch face competition for places

Szoboszlai’s position requires some perspective. Before his hamstring problems, his partnership with Mac Allister had been developing into Iraola’s preferred deeper pairing.

His return has brought less convincing performances, but he is also rebuilding fitness and rhythm. Judging his longer-term suitability solely on those appearances would overlook that context.

The Fenerbahce defeat illustrated the difficulty of finding his best role. Used behind the striker, he struggled to influence proceedings. Under Iraola, that position demands creativity and the ability to support the centre-forward, making it a distinct assignment within the current system.

Gravenberch presents another question. The Athletic’s analysis identifies the No 8 role as the position in which he has performed most convincingly this season.

His heel injury has interrupted his availability, while competition from Mac Allister and Szoboszlai has complicated his route back into the side. Versatility remains useful, but establishing where he contributes most effectively may matter more than the number of positions he can cover.

Wirtz improvement leaves selection debate open

Wirtz’s recent improvement strengthens his case for the advanced midfield role, although greater consistency is still required.

Behind him, the choice need not become a permanent contest with fixed winners. Liverpool’s schedule will demand contributions from all five midfielders, and Nyoni’s workload needs careful handling as his involvement increases.

The Athletic also notes that Nyoni and Szoboszlai, an encouraging partnership during pre-season, have yet to start together as the deeper pair in a competitive match this campaign.

There are therefore combinations still to explore.

Iraola’s task is to find relationships that work across different opponents and match situations. Nyoni has changed the available options, while Mac Allister has supplied continuity. Turning those encouraging individual contributions into a midfield that controls games more consistently remains the next challenge.