Xabi Alonso Returns to Anfield: Memories, Admiration, and Unfinished Dreams

Rival managers seldom receive warm welcomes at Anfield, but Xabi Alonso will undoubtedly be the exception. His legacy with Liverpool FC, forged during a five-year spell that saw him become an adored figure among the Reds, endures as one of class, humility, and immense talent. With Bayer Leverkusen visiting Merseyside, this marks the first competitive fixture where Alonso faces Liverpool since his departure to Real Madrid over 15 years ago. The Athletic‘s James Pearce, who was responsible for the original article, delved into Alonso’s journey and lasting impact, bringing forth perspectives from former teammates and Liverpool faithful alike.

Icon of the 2005 Champions League Triumph

Alonso’s tenure at Liverpool is perhaps best encapsulated by the 2005 Champions League final against AC Milan, a match that cemented his place in the annals of football history. As part of the team that staged one of the greatest comebacks in the sport, Alonso’s crucial role in that Istanbul night made him a hero on Merseyside. Reflecting on his time, he mused, “Expectations were high when I arrived, but the moments and the feelings were even better.”

It was more than just one night in Istanbul, though. Alonso’s 210 appearances for Liverpool showcased his tactical awareness, pinpoint passing, and a remarkable ability to control the pace of the game. Former Liverpool captain Steven Gerrard captured the sentiment perfectly, writing in his autobiography, “Top signing. Pure class. Touch, vision, the creative works.” Jamie Carragher echoed this, noting Alonso’s unique skill set: “Xabi had a great understanding of the game… so talented but he wasn’t a fancy-dan midfielder who let the fella next to him do the running and the tackling. He always did his fair share of that.”

The Charm of Anfield Beckons Again

Tonight, as Alonso steps onto the Anfield turf, it will be in a new capacity, as manager of Bundesliga-winning Leverkusen. His presence will be an emotional reminder for fans who once imagined him as Liverpool’s future manager. When Jurgen Klopp announced his exit in January, Alonso was initially favoured to take over. Yet, he ruled himself out in March, leaving Liverpool’s sporting director, Richard Hughes, to find an alternative. Hughes’ search ultimately led him to Arne Slot, whose promising start has endeared him to fans and reinforced his appointment’s wisdom.

Liverpool’s fanbase, however, holds an undying affection for Alonso. Speaking on the eve of the match, Alonso remarked, “I know the city very well… I loved it and I have friends here. Maybe tomorrow I will go for a walk or a run but I won’t have time for tourism. My focus is only on the game.” It’s clear that for him, Liverpool is not merely an old stomping ground but a second home.

The Gentle Giant of Liverpool’s Midfield

Alonso’s impact extended beyond his performances on the pitch. He quickly won over teammates and fans alike, not only for his footballing prowess but for his humility and professionalism. Former Liverpool goalkeeper Chris Kirkland reflected, “Xabi was one of those lads who you got on with straight away… Top-class player but also a brilliant guy.” Alonso’s commitment to the club’s ethos extended off the pitch; instead of residing in the typical footballers’ neighbourhoods, he chose an apartment in the Royal Albert Dock, integrating into the community in ways few players do.

Neil Mellor, another former teammate, captured Alonso’s deep connection to Liverpool: “He wouldn’t jump on a plane back to Spain if he had a day or two off. His outlook was: ‘This is my home now.’” Alonso embraced the city’s culture, regularly attending local events, dining at La Vina, and visiting places like the Beatles Museum, which endeared him further to the Liverpool faithful.

Loyalty Tested and Legacy Strengthened

While Alonso’s relationship with Liverpool was one of mutual admiration, it wasn’t without challenges. In the summer of 2008, manager Rafael Benitez made the controversial decision to consider selling Alonso, a move that puzzled both fans and players. In one pre-season match, fans voiced their displeasure with chants like, “You can stick your Gareth Barry up your a***,” in response to Benitez’s attempt to sign Barry as a potential replacement. Alonso ultimately stayed for another season, delivering one of his finest campaigns in 2008-09, where Liverpool narrowly missed out on the Premier League title.

Reflecting on this period, Carragher added, “I think most people found it strange that Rafa wanted Barry to come in… there was no comparison between the players.” Despite the speculation and managerial tactics, Alonso maintained his dignity, choosing not to publicly criticise the club. When he finally left for Real Madrid in 2009, it was with the understanding that his relationship with Liverpool was still intact—a rare feat in modern football.

A Career of Unwavering Loyalty and Excellence

Alonso’s career trajectory took him to two other European giants—Real Madrid and Bayern Munich—where he continued to amass accolades, from La Liga and Champions League titles to Bundesliga triumphs. Even during these illustrious years, he never forgot his connection with Liverpool. As he explained in 2017, “I played for the best club in England, the best club in Spain and the best club in Germany.”

Alonso’s decision to never play for another English club further endeared him to Liverpool fans, underscoring his loyalty. Tonight’s return to Anfield as an opposing manager is a rare and poignant moment. His tactical acumen has led Leverkusen to significant achievements, positioning him as one of Europe’s most promising managerial talents.

Our View – Anfield Index Analysis

Excited: Liverpool supporters will greet Alonso with open arms and a sense of nostalgia. While some may regret that he isn’t the one leading the team from the home dugout, there’s an undeniable excitement to see him on the touchline. Arne Slot’s impressive start has quelled doubts over Liverpool’s managerial future, but the “what could have been” sentiment lingers whenever Alonso is mentioned. Could Liverpool have made even greater strides with Alonso at the helm? Fans will cheer him on, but they’ll always wonder.