Liverpool Search for Answers as Isak Faces Scrutiny Over Slow Start

Isak’s Early Struggles Under the Spotlight

Liverpool’s investment in Alexander Isak was supposed to be the attacking spark that propelled their season forward. Instead, the early months have been marked by frustration, injuries and rising debate among supporters eager to understand why one of the Premier League’s most exciting strikers has yet to ignite at Anfield. Many expected the number nine to walk into the starting XI, link naturally with Mohamed Salah and Florian Wirtz and instantly elevate the side’s attacking rhythm. Last season’s form suggested he would flourish.

Reality has hit differently. A combination of fitness setbacks and disrupted preparation has seen Isak labelled as one of the most disappointing signings of the window. Even with injuries acknowledged, there is a growing sense that he has not maximised the opportunities he has had. Arne Slot will know that patience is thinning, especially with Liverpool’s title ambitions looking fragile.

Hutchison Points Finger at Isak for Poor Form

Former Liverpool midfielder Don Hutchison has been blunt about the situation. With Isak nearing a return and already back in the Sweden squad under Graham Potter, the pressure to deliver is only intensifying. Supporters, aware of the £125 million outlay, are questioning the path that brought him to Anfield and whether the forward could have handled it differently.

Hutchison did not hold back in his assessment.
“Totally his own fault. He should have been professional, done his pre-season properly with Newcastle. It was only ever gonna be 1 of 2 outcomes,” he wrote via his personal X account.
“1. He goes to Liverpool and is 100% first, ready to play!
“2. He stays at Newcastle and is ready to play.”

His argument centres on professionalism and preparation. For a player of Isak’s calibre, arriving undercooked can have a ripple effect across an entire campaign.

Transfer Turmoil Creates Ripple Effects

Isak’s route to Liverpool was dramatic. His refusal to play for Newcastle ultimately forced the deal through, satisfying his desire for a move but disrupting his rhythm at a crucial stage. Last season he was electric at St James’ Park, the focal point of their attack and one of the league’s most complete forwards.

That dynamic has shifted. Liverpool are packed with high-level performers and the responsibility traditionally falls on Salah to be the match winner. Even he has found the season demanding and the knock-on effect has been amplified by Isak’s limited involvement.

What Comes Next for Liverpool and Isak

If Isak had opted for a straightforward transfer request rather than a standoff, Liverpool might now be looking at a fully conditioned striker leading their line. Instead, Slot has been forced to juggle selection dilemmas and the club’s pursuit of Premier League and Champions League glory has felt more complicated than it needed to be.

The coming weeks will be crucial. With fitness returning and competition intensifying, Liverpool need Isak to rediscover the sharpness that made him such a coveted signing. For the player, this is an opportunity to reset the narrative. For the club, it is a chance to validate their heavy investment.