Journalist Defends Liverpool Star After Brutal Jamie Carragher Comments

Milos Kerkez has become one of Liverpool’s most dissected summer signings. When Jamie Carragher quipped that having Kerkez at left-back was “like having Darwin Nunez at left-back,” the line made you cringe. It was brutal and unfair, at least in the view of David Lynch, who addressed the remarks after speaking to Dave Davis for Anfield Index.

Lynch pushed back while carefully acknowledging Carragher’s pedigree. “I think it’s harsh. I’m very wary of disagreeing with Jamie Carragher because he’s usually proved right with these sort of things.” He added a necessary layer of respect, “He has forgotten more about being a defender in the Premier League than I would remember in my life, so I’m saying this respectfully, but I don’t agree.” 

Upward Trend Worth Tracking

The £40m deal to bring the 22-year-old from Bournemouth invited expectation. Early season performances were, as Lynch noted, met with excessive heat. “I think Kerkez has been much better lately and I think people were going in on him too much at the start of the season.” Recent displays back this up. While the final ball still needs refinement, “His end product could be a bit better,” the broader developmental curve is pointing the right way. Lynch is clear, “he is still so young and I think he is on an upwards trajectory.”

For a defender learning a new tactical brief at a club with title-winning demands, the first test is adaptability. Kerkez has begun to show it. Defensively, he is tidier in duels, sharper in recovery, and calmer when defending the channel. In attack, his overlaps are more purposeful, his timing more measured. This isn’t a finished article but the key question for Liverpool is whether the trajectory is improving, and whether the player’s profile fits the long-term tactical plan. The answer to both appears to be yes.

Long-Term Fit, Not Panic Buy

Lynch has planted his flag firmly. “I have no doubts that he is the long-term left-back for Liverpool and he’s only going to get better.” Liverpool’s recruitment team clearly targeted age, athleticism, and tactical malleability. Kerkez ticks those boxes. His recent improvement suggests the bedding-in period is working. The club would do well to hold its nerve and continue coaching the details rather than magnifying every imperfect cross.

Kerkez is not the problem, and he may yet become part of the solution.