Jürgen Klopp's Defensive Dilemma

Jürgen Klopp's Defensive Dilemma

What a difference a weekend makes. I was all set to have a piece done on why I thought Mamadou Sakho should he the man to partner Dejan Lovren in the heart of the Liverpool defence this weekend against Watford, only for Craig Gardener to recklessly injure him. Now Liverpool fans are stuck with the thoughts of a Martin Skrtel and Mamadou Sakho centre-back pairing. This pairing for me is the stuff of nightmares because of the weak link in that pairing and the amount of goals that has the potential to be conceded.

Jurgen Klopp Defensive Dilemma

And for me the main culprit for a lot of these goals is Martin Skrtel. He may be seen by some fans as a stalwart of the Liverpool team and somehow he has survived a number of managerial changes including the coming and going of Roy Hodgson, Kenny Dalglish and Brendan Rodgers. He has a record of somehow being the number one defender for each of Liverpool’s last five managers and has seen off defenders like fan favourite Daniel Agger, Sami Hyypia and Jamie Carragher. But if you examine some of the  games he has played, especially in the last eighteen months, how many goals was he himself responsible for? This season alone, you will need to use both your hands to count up the number of goals Skrtel alone has been responsible for. And for some fans he is the one player who can’t be dropped. And heaven forbid if you even mention dropping him you’re attacked left, right and centre.

With Sakho coming back into the team, he’s also the player most Liverpool fans want to see back playing because of his defending and leadership qualities. In Sakho, Liverpool finally have, in my opinion a replacement for long standing servant Jamie Carragher, yes I know that’s a big shout but look at his performances so far this season. When Sakho came into the Liverpool team last season, he along with Emre Can helped to plug a very leaky Liverpool defence. When they came into the team straight away both Simon Mignolet and Martin Skrtel were given a confidence boost. And this season with Sakho out of the team, Liverpool have looked very suspect in defence and have yet again leaked silly goals.

For me I would drop Skrtel completely and have a partnership of Kolo Toure and Sakho until Lovren is fit again. I’ve lost all my faith in Skrtel as a defender and think he’s the only player who hasn’t shown that much improvement under Jürgen Klopp. Look I know for each goal that Skrtel has been responsible for, some will argue that Lovren has been just as culpable for others. The difference for me is that under Klopp, Lovren has somewhat improved his form and his defending. Lovren under Jürgen Klopp is back playing simple football, doing the basics right, not panicking on the ball, not taking any stupid risks in and around the box as much and this type of football has boosted him and his confidence and he has shown this confidence boost on the pitch. While he’ll never be a world class defender, I definitely think playing along side Mamadou Sakho, he has the ability to improve his performances even more than he has recently and having Sakho playing along side him in defence his overall positioning will improve as he will only have to worry about defending.

Look I know I’ve made a big call by saying I want Skrtel dropped and a slower and older Toure brought in to the side to replace him but I really think he can’t do any worse than Skrtel at this point. And maybe, just maybe an experienced Toure coming in to the team will give Simon Mignolet a much needed boost and Liverpool fans won’t see a repeat of the mistakes a la Bordeaux and more recently West Bromwich Albion. As we approach the weekend Jürgen Klopp has some massive decisions to make in relation to team selection. Does he replace Mignolet and does he pair Sakho and Toure in defence instead of Skrtel and Sakho. Whatever Klopp does, he’ll have his own reasoning for doing so. Just as long as he doesn’t decide to play Christan Benteke up front on his own again and fans will be happy.

Comments

6 responses to “Jürgen Klopp’s Defensive Dilemma”

  1. Redownunder says:

    you are a stupid idiot, go & earn your living cleaning shit. No brainer, complete dick head.

  2. badou says:

    dude, you definitely need to change job.you write bollocks that u pull from ur @r$£ n its not even backed up by any stats or anything.
    Skrtel is our most efficient defender in terms of passing interceptions blocks aerial duel tackles based on stats. Go do some research before spouting boollsh!t.
    Replacing him with an ageing and past its best player like toure?! What r u smoking? N did u seriously say that lovren is better than skrtel?! did u miss the matches where lovren mistakes directle led to goals? did u even watch the match? r u even a lfc fan?
    Seriously man, this thing u r smoking must b really strong. Quit taking it. U r already lack enough brain cells. dont make it worse…

  3. Marco says:

    I can see what you’re saying has some validity to it, but I think Skrtel gets way too much stick.

    Our defence has actually always been pretty good in terms of personnel, but either managed badly (man & tactically – BR era) or had a shocking keeper behind them.

    From the style of Skrtel’s play, you can see he picked up a lot of what Carra left behind; the last ditch timed slide. The command of the defence etc.

    He’s had to play with a variety of people over the years & is consistently solid. Our main problem lies with our goalkeeper & our inexplicable lack of team ability to defend set pieces for the past 3-4 years. It’s unfair to pin our woes on Skrtel.

  4. Bobedy says:

    I agree that Skrtel is the weak part of our team. My favoured pairing heading forward is definitly Lovren-Sakho but to suggest Toure should be starting is ridiculous

  5. Mal Swift says:

    Totally agree with this article. We should have got shot of Skrtel ages ago. Why he’s feted by some fans is beyond me. Always out of position, always gives away stupid free kicks and no pace. Only through injuries does he stay in. As with Mignolet he’s a complete liability.

  6. Aido says:

    Agree that Skrtel has been our primary defensive liability for some time now. Where I disagree is that I think JK has been spared a dilemma with Lovren’s injury. With Sakho due to return, the question would surely have been which of Skrtel and Lovren gets dropped and I would certainly favour a Sakho & Lovren partnership. I can’t see Kolo as the solution, as much as I admire the man … his day has come and gone I’m afraid.

Leave a Reply

Your e-mail address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Published by Anfield Index
Updated: 2015-12-16 08:12:52
50 Views