Liverpool’s Dilemma: Should They Pursue Karim Adeyemi?

In the latest episode of The Daily Red podcast, hosted by Dave Hendrick on Anfield Index, the discussion centred around potential transfer targets for Liverpool, including the intriguing option of Borussia Dortmund’s Karim Adeyemi. Adeyemi’s name has resurfaced in transfer rumours, but Hendrick dissected the German’s current situation and suitability for Liverpool.

Karim Adeyemi: Talent or Risk?

At just 22 years old, Karim Adeyemi is undoubtedly a player with enormous potential. However, his journey at Borussia Dortmund has not been entirely smooth. Hendrick pointed out, “Since going to Dortmund, he hasn’t quite hit the heights that were expected of him.” Adeyemi’s last season at Red Bull Salzburg showcased his abilities, where he scored 23 goals. However, in his two seasons at Dortmund, his performances have been inconsistent, netting only 19 goals in all competitions.

Hendrick noted that a combination of factors has hampered Adeyemi’s progress: “The first thing that jumps out is the low number of games and then the lack of goal-scoring production.” Injuries have played a significant role in limiting his appearances. He has missed a total of 58 games in his young career, a worrying statistic for any club considering making an investment in him. “Injuries have disrupted his rhythm and that’s why you’d have pause before committing to buying a player like him,” Hendrick remarked.

Liverpool’s Current Needs in the Forward Line

Liverpool’s current forward options include established stars like Mohamed Salah, Luis Díaz, and Diogo Jota, supported by Federico Chiesa, Cody Gakpo and Darwin Núñez. Hendrick suggested that signing Adeyemi would not immediately elevate the team’s quality: “If Mo were to leave next summer, Adeyemi is not ready to step in and replace what Mo does—he just isn’t.” The young German’s lack of consistent output makes him a risky choice for a club looking for an instant impact, especially if Salah, who remains pivotal, were to depart.

Hendrick did acknowledge that Adeyemi could potentially be a future star but expressed doubt over the timing. “He’s not going to be happy coming in at 23 and just sitting and watching week after week,” he stated, raising concerns about Adeyemi’s development if he were to arrive at Anfield as a backup. It’s clear that Liverpool need someone who can immediately compete for a starting role, rather than another project player.

The Red Bull Connection: A Familiar Path

Liverpool have had past success with players who came through the Red Bull system, such as Sadio Mane. Hendrick recognised this, explaining that “players cultivated in their system tend to do quite well for us.” Adeyemi, with his roots at Red Bull Salzburg, possesses similar qualities: explosive pace, strong 1v1 skills, and the ability to play in various attacking roles.

However, Hendrick warned that these traits alone are not enough: “It would be hard to get him to the point of being ready to start for us.” Dave argued that for Liverpool to bring in a player like Adeyemi, they would have to be prepared for a long-term project rather than expecting immediate dividends. The development path for a young forward must be carefully managed to ensure he reaches his potential, especially when competing for minutes with seasoned players.

What’s the Verdict?

While Karim Adeyemi remains a name to watch, Hendrick’s analysis suggested that now may not be the right time for Liverpool to make a move. The podcast emphasised the need for the club to prioritise signings who can make an immediate impact. Given Adeyemi’s injury history and inconsistent performances, Liverpool should perhaps look elsewhere or consider revisiting the situation once the young German has demonstrated sustained growth at a higher level.

As Hendrick concluded, “There’s no doubting the talent, but it might be best to pass on that, as talented as he is.”