Anthony Gordon vs Luis Díaz: Liverpool’s Dilemma Between Promise and Proven Output

In the Transfer Market Metrics podcast, Dave Davis and Dr Phil Barter revisited the much-discussed interest from Liverpool in Anthony Gordon of Newcastle United. A name heavily linked last summer, Gordon has resurfaced again on Liverpool’s radar—despite Luis Díaz enjoying a standout season.

“Anthony Gordon is still seriously being looked at by Liverpool whether we like it or not,” Davis stated, making clear that this isn’t just paper talk. The conversation took on greater nuance as both hosts analysed Gordon’s output, role, and suitability for Arne Slot’s Liverpool—particularly in light of Díaz’s current form.

Barter confirmed, “Gordon’s got nine goals and seven assists in all competitions… but Díaz has 16 goals and eight assists,” adding plainly, “he beats him in goal contributions.” From an output perspective, the difference is clear.

Stat Breakdown: Díaz Dominates the Metrics

While Gordon is younger at 24, and fits the homegrown quota, the data shows a steep hill to climb. “Pass completion – that’s a huge difference,” said Barter. “That is three rings of the wheel better for Díaz than Gordon.”

On ball progression, Gordon holds his own in areas like progressive carries and shot-creating actions—“he’s in the 80th percentile, four and a half a game,” noted Barter. But even then, Díaz is stronger across the board in take-ons, touches, and end product.

“Díaz takes more players on, has more goal involvements, better passing stats—he’s just more polished,” Barter concluded.

Fit in Liverpool’s System

The question isn’t just stats—it’s tactical fit. Davis noted: “Newcastle play in a medium or deep block and Gordon is often the out ball. Liverpool is a possession-based side. He’d have to learn to play in a more structured way.”

Barter agreed: “There would be some tweaks he’d have to make. At Newcastle, he’s not asked to do the same things.”

Moreover, Gordon’s defensive contribution is limited. “He’s not going to do tackles, he’s not going to be involved in clearances or interceptions,” Barter explained. For a Liverpool wide player, that matters—especially when Slot’s system demands pressing and defensive engagement from the front line.

The Verdict: Why Replace Díaz?

Both hosts wrestled with the logic of potentially replacing Luis Díaz—who just had his best season for Liverpool—with Gordon. “He’s been a real pivotal part for us winning the title,” said Davis. “He’s actually reached Mané levels this year.”

Even when contract situations and long-term squad planning were considered, the argument for Gordon fell flat. “If we were going to move a player on, I’d want it to be for a better upgrade,” Davis added. “And Gordon, based on this season, isn’t that.”

Barter agreed, summarising the situation: “A year ago, you could’ve made the case. But the year hasn’t been kind to Gordon. And Díaz has gone from streaky to consistent.”