Jean-Philippe Mateta to Liverpool? Why It Feels Unlikely

Liverpool fans are still riding the high of a Premier League title under Arne Slot, with new signings like Giorgi Mamardashvili, Jeremie Frimpong, Florian Wirtz, Milos Kerkez and Freddie Woodman strengthening the squad. Yet, as Darwin Nunez edges closer to a summer exit, the focus turns to finding a new striker. Jean-Philippe Mateta’s name has emerged, but there are real doubts about whether he is the right fit.

Mateta’s Qualities at a Glance

Jean-Philippe Mateta delivered 14 goals last season for Crystal Palace and has proven himself a strong Premier League forward. He has good physical presence, can hold up the ball and links well with wide players. At 6’4”, he offers height, creativity and unpredictability, traits Liverpool have valued in the past.

However, at 28, Mateta is not an investment for the long term. While his goal return and Premier League experience are appealing, the price being mentioned, around £60 million, feels steep for a player approaching the later stages of his career.

Bigger Needs for Liverpool

Liverpool are not looking for “good enough” players, they are looking for elite forwards who can keep the club at the top of English and European football. Alexander Isak remains the dream signing, but with Newcastle United unwilling to sell and Hugo Ekitike already joining them, that door seems closed. Joao Pedro was another interesting name, but he has gone to Chelsea.

With limited options available, Liverpool might be better off exploring tactical flexibility, perhaps using a false-nine system like they did with Luis Diaz last season, or simply waiting until next summer when an elite signing might be more achievable.

Why Waiting Makes Sense

While Mateta could provide short-term help, he feels more like a wildcard option rather than the focal point of Slot’s Liverpool. Patience might serve Liverpool better, allowing them to hold out for the right striker instead of rushing into a move that carries financial and sporting risk. For a club with big ambitions, settling for less could harm their momentum.

This is an abridged version; the full article is available on our ‘It Was Always… Liverpool’ Substack page: