Isak’s Move from Newcastle to Liverpool Sparks Debate
Alexander Isak’s record-breaking £125 million transfer from Newcastle United to Liverpool was one of the defining moments of the summer window. Yet only months into his Anfield career, questions are emerging over whether the move was handled correctly. The Swedish striker’s decision to force an exit from St James’ Park — skipping pre-season and missing early fixtures — has now come under scrutiny, particularly as he battles ongoing fitness issues.
Liverpool supporters were told to expect an explosive new forward to complement Arne Slot’s high-tempo attack, but so far, Isak’s contributions have been limited. After featuring in just eight matches, he was left out of the squad for Liverpool’s recent clash with Brentford due to a recurring groin problem.
That absence, according to some observers, is not merely bad luck but the direct consequence of how Isak managed his summer departure.
Chris Sutton Questions Isak’s Preparation
Former Premier League striker Chris Sutton has publicly questioned Isak’s professionalism in the lead-up to his move. Writing in his BBC Sport column, Sutton argued that the striker’s refusal to train with Newcastle had long-term consequences on his sharpness.
“It feels like what has happened to him is a case of you reap what you sow,” Sutton wrote. “Isak has been short of full fitness and sharpness all season. He didn’t help himself by missing training with Newcastle to force his move to Anfield. He got what he wanted, but now he’s playing catch-up instead of hitting the ground running. That’s when you’re more likely to pick up injuries.”
Sutton went further, suggesting that Isak’s situation has affected Liverpool’s attacking rhythm as a whole. “He’s too good a player not to score goals eventually,” Sutton continued, “but his lack of readiness has affected Liverpool’s fluency in the final third.”
Ekitike Takes Advantage of Isak’s Absence
While Isak continues his recovery, Hugo Ekitike has seized the opportunity to impress. The Frenchman, who arrived from Frankfurt for £79 million, has already notched six goals and one assist in his first 13 appearances. Initially expected to compete with Isak for the central striking role, Ekitike has quickly established himself as the more reliable option for Slot.
It’s an awkward dynamic for Liverpool, who invested heavily in both forwards. While the club saw Isak as a marquee acquisition to elevate their attack, it’s the younger and less expensive Ekitike who has adapted more quickly to life on Merseyside.
The contrasting fortunes of the two strikers underline the fine margins at elite level football — where preparation and attitude often dictate early success.
Slot Calls for Patience as Isak Rebuilds
Liverpool manager Arne Slot has urged patience, defending the club’s record signing amid growing external pressure. “When he came, he had hardly trained,” Slot explained earlier this week. “We try to prepare players for once-a-week football, but at Liverpool, we play every three days. Without pre-season, it’s not easy to get players ready for that intensity.”
Slot’s words hint at a longer-term integration plan, but also at frustration that Isak’s delayed fitness has disrupted Liverpool’s attacking development. The expectation remains that, once fit, the Swede’s movement and finishing will add a new dimension to the Reds’ front line.
Until then, Liverpool must strike a balance between managing Isak’s workload and maintaining consistency in front of goal — something that, according to Sutton and others, may prove costly if not addressed soon.
