Liverpool’s reported interest in Bournemouth forward Antoine Semenyo has reignited debate around the club’s transfer strategy, especially in light of a faltering title defence that has seen Arne Slot’s side lose five of their last six Premier League matches. Sitting eighth in the table and eight points behind leaders Arsenal, questions are growing about whether bolstering the attack should really be the club’s focus right now.

On Anfield Index’s ‘Transfer Market Metrics’ podcast, Dave Davis shed light on the situation, revealing: “Liverpool have got a solid interest in Antoine Semenyo.” He went on to explain the reasoning behind that admiration, noting, “I get why. He has raw pace, great physical attributes and a clear ability to beat his man. There should be no surprise that Liverpool are interested in him.”

However, Davis also pointed out that “Liverpool had a solid look at him in the summer and opted not to make a move.”

Concerns Over Spending and Squad Balance

Dr Phil Barter, speaking to Dave Davis on the same podcast, offered a more cautious assessment of the reported £75 million valuation for the Bournemouth forward. “I struggle to see the need to spend that money on an attacker,” he said, highlighting a broader concern over where Liverpool’s real problems lie.

Barter added, “The reason why Liverpool are in the situation they are the moment, is not because of the attack, it’s because we can’t keep clean sheets and we can’t stop conceding first.” His words reflect a frustration many supporters share after watching the Reds repeatedly fall behind in recent matches.

With Arne Slot’s system still adapting post-Klopp, defensive instability has been a recurring theme, with lapses in concentration and individual mistakes costing Liverpool valuable points. In that context, investing heavily in a forward might appear counterintuitive, especially when the current forward line has shown it can create and score goals even during poor spells.

Semenyo’s Strengths and the Wider Picture

There’s little doubt about Semenyo’s quality. His performances for Bournemouth have been full of energy and unpredictability, often causing problems for defenders with his direct style and power. Yet while he fits Liverpool’s mould for dynamic attackers, his signing might be seen as a luxury rather than a necessity.

Dr Barter’s comments underscored that sentiment: “You could sign Semenyo and hope to out-score teams every week, but that’s not a long-term solution.” The statement cuts to the heart of Liverpool’s current dilemma. A club once built on defensive resilience and controlled pressing now appears too open and vulnerable, particularly against sides capable of quick transitions.

Time for Defensive Reinforcement

As the January window approaches, the conversation around Liverpool’s recruitment priorities will only intensify. Slot’s squad requires stability, leadership, and depth in defensive areas more than another forward option. While Semenyo’s name might appeal to those seeking flair and pace, the numbers suggest Liverpool’s real problems start at the back.

Dr Barter’s analysis offers a timely reminder that unless Liverpool rediscover their defensive discipline, no attacking addition will be enough to reignite their season.